Categories: Insurance

ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life Plan: Good or Bad? An Insightful ULIP Review

Listen to this article

Can the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life Plan truly deliver lifelong protection along with meaningful wealth creation, or does combining both come with important trade-offs?

Does the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life Plan offer the right balance between market-linked growth and life insurance, or are there better alternatives available?

Can the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life Plan help you achieve your long-term financial goals, or do its costs and restrictions deserve closer scrutiny?

This article takes a closer look at the key features, benefits, and potential drawbacks of the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life Plan. It also examines whether combining decreasing life coverage with market-linked investments is the right financial strategy for securing your family’s future.

Table of Contents:

What is the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life?

What are the features of the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life?

Who is eligible for the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life?

What are the benefits of the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life?

Death benefit

Maturity Benefit

Other benefits

What are the investment strategies and fund options in the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life?

What are the charges of the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life?

Grace Period, Discontinuance and Revival of the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life

Free Look Period for the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life

Surrendering the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life

What are the advantages of the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life?

What are the disadvantages of the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life?

Research Methodology of ICICI Protect N Gain Whole Life

Benefit Illustration – IRR Analysis of ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life

ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life Vs. Other Investments

ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life Vs. Pure-term + Equity Mutual Fund

Final Verdict on the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life

What is the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life?

ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life is a Non-Participating, Linked, Individual, savings life insurance plan. It is a protection-oriented unit-linked savings life insurance plan, designed to safeguard your family while supporting your evolving life goals.

What are the features of the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life?

  • Secure your family’s future with life insurance coverage up to 99 years of age.
  • Build your wealth with the potential for market-linked returns.
  • Stay invested until maturity and receive a Maturity Booster as a reward for policy continuation.
  • Create a supplementary income stream with monthly payouts through the Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP).
  • Boost your Fund Value with loyalty additions allocated as additional units.
  • Enhance your Fund Value with a Cover Continuance Booster in the form of additional units.
  • Avail potential tax benefits on premiums paid and benefits received, subject to prevailing tax laws.

Who is eligible for the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life?

Plan Option Limited pay
Premium Payment Term (in years) 7 – 12 years
Policy term 99 years less Entry age
Minimum/maximum age at entry 18/50 years
Minimum/maximum age at maturity 99 years
Minimum Sum Assured ₹ 50,00,000
Premium Payment Frequency Annual, Half-yearly, Monthly
Minimum premium Corresponding to the minimum sum assured
Maximum Premium and Sum assured Board approval

What are the benefits of the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life?

1. Death benefit

If the person whose life is covered by this ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life Plan policy (known as the Life Assured) passes away the Policy Term, the insurance cover amount will be paid out as a lump sum to the Cl, provided the policy is in force, and the monies are not in the Discontinued Policy Fund.

Death Benefit will be the highest of:

  • Fund Value as available on the date of intimation of death or the date of Foreclosure/Maturity, whichever is earlier
  • Minimum Death Benefit
  • Maximum of (10 x Annualised Premium) or (Death benefit factor x Sum Assured)
  • Top-up Sum Assured (if any)

The death benefit factors will vary by Policy Years as per the table:

Policy year Death Benefit Factor
≤ 66 less Entry Age 1
67 less Entry Age 0.8
68 less Entry Age 0.6
69 less Entry Age 0.4
70 less Entry Age 0.2
≥ 71 less Entry Age 0.1

2. Maturity Benefit

On survival of the Life Assured until the end of the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life Plan policy term, i.e. at policy maturity, provided the policy has not already terminated, you will receive the Fund Value.

On payment of Maturity Benefit, the policy will terminate, and all rights, benefits and interests under the policy will be extinguished.

3. Other benefits

Return of charges:

Return of premium allocation charge: From the beginning of the 11th policy year, the premium allocation charges (excluding taxes and top-up premium allocation charges) deducted from the policy in the 120th month prior to the policy month will be added back to the fund value in the form of addition of units in a corresponding manner.

Return of mortality charges: Starting from the 11th policy year, at the beginning of each policy month, the mortality charge (excluding underwriting extra premium, extra mortality charges and taxes), deducted from the policy in the 120th month prior to the policy month, will be added back to the Fund Value in the form of addition of units.

Loyalty Additions

Loyalty Additions will be allocated as extra units from Policy Year (67 less Entry Age) and onwards, at the end of each Policy Year, provided all due premiums have been paid. Each Loyalty Addition will be 0.50% of the average of Fund Values on the last business day of the last eight policy quarters.

Maturity Booster

Maturity Booster will be allocated as extra units at the end of the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life Plan Policy Term to boost your Fund Value, provided the policy is in force.

This Maturity Booster will be 20% of the average of the Fund Value on the last business day of the last eight policy quarters.

What are the investment strategies and fund options in the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life?

Choice of Funds

As per your savings outlook & risk appetite, you can choose from a range of funds to save your money.

The names of various funds available along with their risk-reward profile are given in the table below:

S. no Fund Name Asset Allocation Risk Profile
Equity and Equity-related Securities Debt Money market and cash
1 Focus 50 Fund 90-100% 0-10% 0-10% High
2 India Growth 80-100% 0-20% 0-20% High
3 Opportunities Fund 80-100% 0-20% 0-20% High
4 Value Enhancer Fund 85-100% 0-15% 0-15% High
5 Multi Cap Growth Fund 80-100% 0-20% 0-20% High
6 Blue-chip Fund 80-100% 0-20% 0-20% High
7 Maximiser V 75-100% 0-25% 0-25% High
8 Maximise India Fund 80-100% 0-20% 0-20% High
9 Multi Cap Balanced Fund 0-60% 20-70% 0-50% Moderate
10 Active Asset Allocation Balanced Fund 30-70% 30-70% 0-40% Moderate
11 Secure Opportunities Fund 0% 60-100% 0-40% Low
12 Income Fund 0% 40-100% 0-60% Low
13 Money Market Fund 0% 0-50% 50-100% Low
14 Balanced Advantage Fund 65-90% 10-35% 0-35% High
15 Sustainable Equity Fund 85-100% 0-15% 0-15% High
16 Mid-Cap Fund 85-100% 0-15% 0-15% High
17 Mid-Cap Hybrid Growth Fund 65-80% 20-35% 0-15% High
18 Constant Maturity Fund 0% 75-100% 0-25% Moderate
19 Mid-cap Index Fund 90-100% 0-10% 0-10% High
20 Mid-cap 150 Momentum 50 Index Fund 90-100% 0-10% 0-10% High
21 Multicap 50 25 25 Index Fund 90-100% 0-10% 0-10% High
22 MidSmall cap 400 Index Fund 90-100% 0-10% 0-10% High
23 MidSmallCap 400 Momentum Quality 100 Index Fund: 90-100% 0-10% 0-10% High
24 Smallcap 250 Momentum Quality 100 Index Fund 90-100% 0-10% 0-10% High
25 India Consumption Fund 90-100% 0-10% 0-10% High
26 Nifty Alpha 50 Index Fund 90-100% 0-10% 0-10% High
27 BSE 500 Enhanced Value 50 Index Fund 90-100% 0-10% 0-10% High
28 Sector Leaders Index Fund 90-100% 0-10% 0-10% High
29 Dividend Leaders 50 Index Fund 90-100% 0-10% 0-10% High
30 Smallcap 250 Index Fund 90-100% 0-10% 0-10% High
31 BSE Enhanced Value 30 Index Fund 80-100% 0-20% 0-20% High
32 Large & Mid Cap Advantage Fund 80-100% 0-20% 0-20% High
33 BSE 500 Momentum Value 50 Index Fund 80-100% 0-20% 0-20% High

Choice of Portfolio Strategies

You can choose from four portfolio strategies to save your money as per your risk appetite. These are given below:

i. Fixed Portfolio Strategy

Under this strategy, you can choose to save your money in any of the following fund options in the proportions of your choice. You can switch your investment amount amongst these funds using the switch option.

Within the Fixed Portfolio Strategy, you also have the option to select Automatic Transfer Strategy (ATS).

To protect your savings against market uncertainties, you can save all or part of your savings in one or more debt/ equity fund(s) and transfer a fixed amount regularly to one or more equity/ debt fund(s).

Premium redirection and Unlimited free switches between funds are allowed for Fixed Portfolio Strategy.

ii. Target Asset Allocation Strategy

This strategy enables you to choose an asset allocation that is best suited to your risk appetite and maintains it throughout the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life Plan policy term.

You can allocate your premiums between any two funds available with this policy, in the proportion of your choice. Your portfolio will be rebalanced every quarter to ensure that this asset allocation is maintained.

iii. Trigger Portfolio Strategy 2

Under this strategy, your savings will initially be distributed between two funds: Multi Cap Growth Fund, an equity-oriented fund, and Income Fund, a debt-oriented fund, in a 75%: 25% proportion.

The fund allocation may subsequently get altered due to market movements. They will rebalance funds in the portfolio based on a trigger event.

iv. Lifecycle-based Portfolio Strategy 2

At Policy inception, your savings are distributed between two funds, Multi Cap Growth Fund and Income Fund, based on your age.

As you move from one age band to another, your funds are redistributed based on your age.

Age of Policyholder (years) Multi Cap Growth Fund Income Fund
Up to 25 80% 20%
26-35 75% 25%
36-45 65% 35%
46-55 55% 45%
56-65 45% 55%
66+ 35% 65%

What are the charges of the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life?

A. Premium allocation charges

It shall be levied in the first 7 policy years as a percentage of the premium as follows:

Year % of premium
Year 1 – 3 6%
Year 4 – 7 3%
Thereafter NIL

B. Fund Management charge

It is 0.75% p.a. for Money market fund and 1.35% p.a. for all other funds. For discontinued policy funds, it is o.50% p.a.

C. Policy Administration charges

It will be levied from the 4th policy year at the beginning of every month. It is 0.34% of the annual premium for the 4th policy year, and thereafter, it will increase by 5% p.a. every year.

D. Mortality Charges

It is the cost of the life insurance cover and depends on your age, gender & chosen sum assured. These charges will be levied every month by redemption of units based on the Sum at Risk.

Age 30 40 50
Male 1.17 2.02 5.32
Female 1.13 1.74 4.24

E. Discontinuance charge

It depends on the year of discontinuance and the annualised premium amount. There is no discontinuance charge from the 5th policy year.

Inference from charges: The plan deducts multiple charges before the premium is invested, including Premium Allocation, Discontinuance, and Mortality Charges. These charges can significantly reduce the amount actually invested and impact long-term returns. Compared with other market-linked investment options, ULIPs generally involve higher and more complex charges, making the investment process less transparent.

Grace Period, Discontinuance and Revival of the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life

Grace Period

The grace period for payment of premium is 15 days for monthly mode of premium payment and 30 days for other modes of premium payment commencing from the premium due date.

Discontinuance

Premium discontinuance during lock-in period: the Fund Value shall be credited to the Discontinued Policy Fund after deduction of applicable discontinuance charges, and the risk cover and rider cover, if any, shall cease. The proceeds of the Discontinued Policy Fund applicable to your policy shall be payable to You at the end of the revival period or lock-in period, whichever is later.

Premium discontinuance after the lock-in period: the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life Plan policy will be converted into a reduced paid-up policy with paid-up sum assured. The policy shall continue to be in reduced paid-up status without rider cover, if any. At the end of the revival period or on the date of maturity, whichever is earlier, the Fund Value (as applicable at the end of the revival period) or the Maturity Benefit (as payable on Date of Maturity) shall become payable to you, and the policy shall terminate.

Revival

You can revive your ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life Plan policy benefits for their full value within three years from the due date of the first unpaid premium.

Free Look Period for the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life

On receipt of the policy document, whether received electronically or otherwise, you have an option to review the policy terms and conditions.

If you are not satisfied or have any disagreement with the terms and conditions of the policy or otherwise and have not made any claim, the policy document needs to be returned to the Company with reasons for cancellation within 30 days from the date of receipt of the policy document.

Surrendering the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life

On surrender during the lock-in period, the unit fund value, after deducting applicable discontinuance charges, shall be credited to the discontinuance policy fund, and the risk cover and rider cover, if any, shall cease.

The fund management charges of the discontinued policy fund will be applicable during this period, and no other charges will be applied.

You or the Claimant, as the case may be, will be entitled to receive the Discontinued Policy Fund Value applicable to your policy, on the earlier of death of the Life Assured or the expiry of the lock-in period. Currently, the lock-in period is five years from policy inception.

In case of surrender of policy after the lock-in period, the surrender value, as on the date of surrender, shall be payable to you.

What are the advantages of the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life?

  • Increase your coverage and Fund Value by investing surplus funds through Top-up premiums over and above your base premium.
  • Access funds when needed through the Partial Withdrawal facility to manage immediate financial requirements.
  • Create a supplementary income stream by opting for a Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP) under the Partial Withdrawal facility.
  • Enjoy greater flexibility by changing your premium payment frequency during the Premium Payment Term, subject to applicable terms and conditions.
  • Protect your family’s financial interests by securing the policy under the Married Women’s Property Act (MWPA), as applicable.

What are the disadvantages of the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life?

  • No policy loan facility: The plan does not offer the option to avail a loan against the policy, which may limit access to funds during financial emergencies.
  • Limited maturity benefit timeline: The maturity benefit is payable only at the end of the policy term, which extends up to 99 years of age. While the death benefit is payable to the nominee upon the policyholder’s death, the long policy duration may limit the practical value of these benefits for the policyholder during their lifetime.
  • Limited differentiation among fund options: The available fund options may appear repetitive, as their asset-allocation patterns are broadly similar, offering limited variation in terms of investment strategy.

Research Methodology of ICICI Protect N Gain Whole Life

The ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life Plan is a whole-of-life policy with a maturity benefit payable at the age of 99.

It provides a death benefit to the nominee, equal to the higher of the applicable Sum Assured or the Fund Value.

However, the Sum Assured reduces significantly over the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life Plan policy term.

Let us examine this structure and calculate the Internal Rate of Return (IRR) based on the figures provided in the policy brochure.

Benefit Illustration – IRR Analysis of ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life

Consider a 40-year-old male who opts for the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life Plan with a Sum Assured of ₹1 Crore.

The policy term is 60 years (100 minus age 40), with a premium-paying term of 10 years and an annual premium of ₹1,33,333.

Male 40 years
Sum Assured ₹ 1,00,00,000
Policy Term Whole Life
Premium Paying Term 10 years
Annualised Premium ₹ 1,33,333

As the Sum Assured reduces with age, the death benefit payable would be the higher of the following:

Age Death benefit will be the higher of
Till Age 65 ₹ 1 Crore or Fund Value
66 ₹ 80 Lakh or Fund Value
67 ₹ 60 Lakh or Fund Value
68 ₹ 40 Lakh or Fund Value
69 ₹ 20 Lakh or Fund Value
70 and above ₹ 13.99 Lakh or Fund Value

The policy illustration considers two assumed rates of investment return—8% p.a. and 4% p.a. These are only assumed rates and are not guaranteed. They should not be interpreted as the maximum or minimum returns that the fund may generate.

At 4% p.a. At 8% p.a.
Age Year Annualised premium / Maturity benefit Annualised premium / Maturity benefit
40 1 -1,33,333 -1,33,333
41 2 -1,33,333 -1,33,333
42 3 -1,33,333 -1,33,333
43 4 -1,33,333 -1,33,333
44 5 -1,33,333 -1,33,333
45 6 -1,33,333 -1,33,333
46 7 -1,33,333 -1,33,333
47 8 -1,33,333 -1,33,333
48 9 -1,33,333 -1,33,333
49 10 -1,33,333 -1,33,333
50 11 0 0
51 12 0 0
52 13 0 0
53 14 0 0
54 15 0 0
55 16 0 0
56 17 0 0
57 18 0 0
58 19 0 0
59 20 0 0
60 21 0 0
61 22 0 0
62 23 0 0
63 24 0 0
64 25 0 0
65 26 0 0
66 27 0 0
67 28 0 0
68 29 0 0
69 30 0 0
70 31 0 0
71 32 0 0
72 33 0 0
73 34 0 0
74 35 0 0
75 36 0 0
76 37 0 0
77 38 0 0
78 39 0 0
79 40 0 0
80 41 0 0
81 42 0 0
82 43 0 0
83 44 0 0
84 45 0 0
85 46 0 0
86 47 0 0
87 48 0 0
88 49 0 0
89 50 0 0
90 51 0 0
91 52 0 0
92 53 0 0
93 54 0 0
94 55 0 0
95 56 0 0
96 57 0 0
97 58 0 0
98 59 0 0
99 60 46,90,019 3,82,62,848
2.33% 6.32%

Now consider the Fund Value at age 99. Under the 4% return scenario, the Fund Value is ₹46.9 Lakh, translating into an IRR of just 2.33% as per the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life Plan maturity calculator.

Under the 8% return scenario, the Fund Value grows to ₹3.82 Crore, with an IRR of 6.32% as per the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life Plan maturity calculator.

However, there is an important limitation. This accumulated Fund Value cannot be freely accessed or utilised during your lifetime unless the policy is surrendered. In other words, a substantial portion of the corpus remains locked within the policy for the duration of the plan.

Moreover, these IRRs are calculated over the entire policy period, effectively up to age 99. If the returns are calculated for an earlier exit or holding period, the IRR would be even lower.

This raises a fundamental question about the suitability of using such a product for wealth creation.

When the returns are market-linked but access to the accumulated corpus remains restricted for most of your lifetime, the very purpose of investing in a market-linked product is undermined.

ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life Vs. Other Investments

Although the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life Plan is a unit-linked product, it may not be suitable for achieving life goals because the accumulated funds remain largely inaccessible during the policy term.

It also provides whole-of-life insurance coverage, which is generally unnecessary from a personal financial planning perspective.

For most individuals, life insurance is primarily required during their working years, when their income needs to be protected for their dependants.

ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life Vs. Pure-term + Equity Mutual Fund

With these limitations in mind, let us consider an alternative strategy that provides adequate life cover while keeping the investment corpus accessible.

For life cover up to age 65, a pure-term life insurance policy with a Sum Assured of ₹1 Crore costs ₹28,900 annually.

With a 25-year policy term and a 10-year premium-paying term, this leaves ₹1,04,433 from the annual amount available for investment.

This balance is invested in an equity mutual fund, a market-linked investment vehicle.

Pure Term Life Insurance Policy
Sum Assured ₹ 1,00,00,000
Policy Term 25 years
Premium Paying Term 10 years
Annualised Premium ₹ 28,900
Investment ₹ 1,04,433

At the end of 25 years, the investment grows to approximately ₹1.12 Crore. After accounting for capital gains tax, the post-tax corpus is approximately ₹99.76 Lakh.

This amount can then be moved to a debt instrument earning an assumed return of 7% p.a. and allowed to grow until age 99.

Under this strategy, the overall IRR works out to approximately 8.32%.

Term insurance + Equity Mutual Fund
Age Year Term Insurance premium + Equity Mutual Fund
40 1 -1,33,333
41 2 -1,33,333
42 3 -1,33,333
43 4 -1,33,333
44 5 -1,33,333
45 6 -1,33,333
46 7 -1,33,333
47 8 -1,33,333
48 9 -1,33,333
49 10 -1,33,333
50 11 0
51 12 0
52 13 0
53 14 0
54 15 0
55 16 0
56 17 0
57 18 0
58 19 0
59 20 0
60 21 0
61 22 0
62 23 0
63 24 0
64 25 0
65 26 0
66 27 0
67 28 0
68 29 0
69 30 0
70 31 0
71 32 0
72 33 0
73 34 0
74 35 0
75 36 0
76 37 0
77 38 0
78 39 0
79 40 0
80 41 0
81 42 0
82 43 0
83 44 0
84 45 0
85 46 0
86 47 0
87 48 0
88 49 0
89 50 0
90 51 0
91 52 0
92 53 0
93 54 0
94 55 0
95 56 0
96 57 0
97 58 0
98 59 0
99 60 10,65,17,749
8.32%
Equity Mutual Fund Tax Calculation
Maturity value after 25 years 1,12,34,970
Purchase price 10,44,330
Long-Term Capital Gains 1,01,90,640
Exemption limit 1,25,000
Taxable LTCG 1,00,65,640
Tax paid on LTCG 12,58,205
Maturity value after tax 99,76,765

More importantly, this approach addresses the key shortcomings of the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life Plan.

You receive ₹1 Crore of life cover until age 65, while the investment corpus remains accessible throughout the investment period and can be utilised whenever required for your life goals.

The key difference is simple: term insurance provides the required protection, while investments remain available to fund your goals.

By separating insurance from investment, you gain greater liquidity, flexibility, and control over your money.

Final Verdict on the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life

A unit-linked product is typically chosen for its potential to generate higher returns, with investors accepting market-related risks.

However, despite being a ULIP, the ICICI Pru Protect N Gain Whole Life Plan offers relatively modest return potential.

More importantly, the Fund Value remains largely inaccessible during the policyholder’s lifetime. It can be used by the nominee as a death benefit, or by the policyholder on surviving until age 99.

Accessing it earlier may require partial withdrawal or surrender, subject to the policy conditions. This significantly limits its usefulness for achieving financial goals.

The relatively low returns, combined with the various charges, make the investment proposition less attractive and it also has a high agent commission.

Combining insurance and investment in one product does not necessarily optimise either objective.

The whole-of-life cover also adds limited value for most individuals while increasing mortality charges.

A pure-term insurance policy covering the working years, combined with a diversified investment portfolio for wealth creation, is generally a more effective approach.

Do Quora, Facebook, and Twitter have the final say when it comes to financial advice?

For selecting the right combination of insurance and investments, a Certified Financial Planner (CFP) can help structure a plan based on your risk profile, time horizon, and financial goals.

Holistic

Recent Posts

ABSLI Index Guaranteed Annuity Plus Plan: Good or Bad? An Insightful Review

Listen to this article Can the ABSLI Index Guaranteed Annuity Plus Plan truly provide dependable…

5 days ago

Tata AIA Life Shubh Flexi Pension Plan: Good or Bad? A Detailed Review

Listen to this article Can the Tata AIA Life Shubh Flexi Pension Plan truly help…

6 days ago

Axis Max Life Forever Young Pension Plan: Good or Bad? An Insightful ULIP Review

Listen to this article Can the Axis Max Life Forever Young Pension Plan truly help…

7 days ago

“Earn Money on Telegram” Task Scams: What They Are and How to Avoid Them

Listen to this article Somebody you have never met just messaged you on Telegram or…

7 days ago

EPF Interest Rate History: How It Compares to PPF

Listen to this article If you've ever glanced at your payslip and wondered where that…

1 week ago

Axis Max Life Smart Wealth Annuity Guaranteed Pension Plan: Good or Bad? A Detailed Review

Listen to this article Can the Axis Max Life Smart Wealth Annuity Guaranteed Pension Plan…

1 week ago