Depreciating Assets Vs Appreciating Assets: Investment Strategies for Wealth Preservation & Creation

Safety of Principal Vs Safety of Purchasing Power: Investment Strategies Compared

Listen to this article


Are you someone who realized that you are losing out on your hard-earned money despite having a wide range of assets? Don’t worry.

Simply noticing the problem already puts you ahead of most people, because many realize it only when it is too late.

The path from here is less problematic if you understand that the issues you think are minor are often the ones that grow into a gigantic hurdle later on.

Let us understand how to tackle this gigantic hurdle called “Depreciating Assets” on the path to financial success!

The Short Answer

An appreciating asset is something whose value tends to rise over time, like equity mutual funds, shares, land and, to a large extent, gold.

A depreciating asset is something that starts losing value the day you start using it, like a car, a phone, a laptop or the interiors of your home.

So, if you have been wondering what the opposite of a depreciating asset is, it is simply an appreciating asset, which in this article we also call a growing asset.

And if you have come across the popular quiz question on which statement about investing is correct, the right answer is that investment is all about owning appreciating assets, not depreciating assets, lifestyle assets or only physical assets.

Table of Contents:

1.) Understanding Appreciating and Depreciating Assets
2.) Impact of Depreciating Assets
3.) Depreciating Assets We Ignore
4.) Buying Depreciating Assets Through Debt
5.) Growing Assets – Be Careful!
6.) Conclusion
7.) Frequently Asked Questions

1.)  Understanding Appreciating and Depreciating Assets


Before going further, let’s be clear about what are appreciating and depreciating assets.

Assets that increase our net worth day by day are growing assets. Assets that reduce our net worth due to depreciation are depreciating assets.

In other words, the opposite of a depreciating asset is an appreciating asset.

One quietly eats into your wealth every year, while the other has the potential to add to it every year.

Examples of growing assets include stock investments, Mutual Funds, gold, and real estate investments.

These have a high chance of increasing in value in the long term.

Examples of depreciating assets include cars, cell phones, electronic devices, and home interior decoration.

Their values are generally declining all the time.

In the Indian context, the appreciating assets most families come across are equity shares, equity mutual funds, gold, and land or well-located real estate.

None of them rises in a straight line, and each comes with its own risks.

But over long periods, they have the potential to grow faster than the cost of living.

Appreciating vs Depreciating Assets at a Glance 

Point

Appreciating Asset

Depreciating Asset

What happens to its value

Has the potential to rise over the long term

Starts falling from the day you buy it

Common examples

Equity shares, equity mutual funds, gold, land

Cars, phones, laptops, home interiors

Effect on your net worth

Can add to it over time

Reduces it year after year

Buying it on a loan

Needs careful planning

Best avoided, as interest adds to the loss

Its role in your plan

Builds wealth for your goals

Serves a need or comfort, so spend within a limit

So what does this mean for you? Both types of assets have a place in life.

The real question is how much of your income goes into each, and whether that mix is moving you closer to your goals.

2.) Impact of Depreciating Assets

Do you want to know the impact depreciating assets have on preventing your net worth from growing?

Let’s say you are buying a new car on loan. You only have ₹5 lakh in cash to buy a car worth ₹15 lakh. You take another ₹10 lakh from the bank at an interest rate of 8%. That is,

Car price = ₹15,00,000

Cash balance = ₹5,00,000

Total loan amount ₹10,00,000

Interest rate = 8%

Loan period = 60 months

EMI = ₹20,276

In case you are wondering whether 8% is realistic today, new-car loans from major banks are currently priced roughly between 7.5% and 9.5% depending on the bank and your credit score, so 8% is a fair middle-of-the-road number for this example.

You have probably only seen the calculations mentioned above so far. Most people decide to buy a car based on this alone. Are these calculations enough to make a decision? Can the right decision be made based on this alone?

Also, look at the following calculations carefully.

Average lifespan of a car = 10-12 years (or) 2,50,000 km – 3,00,000 km

Let’s see what your total expenditure is within 5 years of the car loan being repaid and what the value of the car is that you think of as an asset at the end of 5 years.

Total expenditure amount = ₹5 lakhs + ₹10 lakhs (loan) + ₹2.17 lakhs (interest) + repair & maintenance cost + insurance

The total expenditure will have at least reached ₹20 lakhs.

As per the depreciation schedule insurers use to fix a car’s insured value (IDV), a car that is four to five years old is valued at roughly 50% of its original price.

Based on this, if we look at it, the total expenditure for the car is ₹20 lakhs. The value of the car at the end of 5 years is only ₹7.5 lakhs.

As a result of investing in a depreciating asset, you incur a loss of ₹12.5 lakh!

Let’s say someone invests the same amount in an Equity Mutual Fund SIP.

That is, he invests ₹5 lakhs as an initial investment and also invests ₹20,276 per month as an SIP. At the end of 5 years, with a return of 12% on investment, the value of the Equity Mutual Fund investment will have increased to ₹25.60 lakh.

Please note: Mutual fund investments are subject to market risks. The 12% return used here is only an illustration and is not guaranteed. Actual returns can be higher or lower, and can even be negative over shorter periods

In the case of a car, which is a depreciating asset, the value is ₹7.5 lakh. But in the case of an Equity Mutual Fund, which is a growing asset, the value has increased to ₹25.26 lakh.

The above calculations have been given to make you aware of the impact of depreciating assets and the value of growing assets in your investment strategy.

It is up to each individual to buy car-like depreciating assets depending on their needs, lifestyle, and convenience.

However, it is important to decide how much you can spend carefully, keeping in mind that it is a depreciating asset when you buy it.

It is also important to consider whether the allocation for growing assets is comparatively high.

Here is a simple habit worth building.

Before you buy any depreciating asset on EMI, pause and ask yourself what that same EMI could grow into if it were invested for the same period.

You may still decide to buy the car, and that is perfectly fine. The difference is that you will buy it with your eyes open, knowing its true cost.

3.) Depreciating Assets We Ignore

Is a House or Flat an Appreciating or Depreciating Asset?

This is a question many home buyers ask, and the honest answer is that a house is a bit of both.

The land underneath your house usually appreciates over time, especially in a good location.

The building itself, however, ages every year. Walls, plumbing, wiring, lifts and fittings wear out and need money to maintain, so the structure slowly loses value.

A flat works the same way, with one important difference. You own only an undivided share of the land, so a bigger part of what you paid is for the building.

That is why an older flat in an ageing building can see its price stagnate even when the area around it keeps growing.

So what should you do? When you buy a house, judge it by its location, its land share, and the age and quality of the building.

And remember that the money you spend on interiors is a depreciating asset, as you will see next.

Interior Decoration

The cost of interior decoration for a house is often included in the cost of buying the house, and it is also considered an asset in the minds of many people. Approximately, ₹10 to ₹20 lakh rupees are spent on interior decoration for a 1000 square feet house.

If you sell the house in the future, you cannot sell the interior decoration cost as part of the value of the house. For example, you buy a flat worth 1 crore for 1000 square feet. You spend ₹20 lakhs to decorate it. After 5 years, you plan to sell the flat. The flat without interior decoration is being sold in the market for ₹1.3 crores. The price of your house with interior decoration will be almost the same. You cannot ask for an additional price for the interior.

The buyer may not like the interior decoration we have done and may want to change it, so we cannot specify a separate price for it. Therefore, it is necessary to have a clear perspective to see the house (especially the land underneath it) as a growing asset and interior decoration as a depreciating asset when buying a house. The expenses should be reduced accordingly.

Electronic gadgets

Many of us upgrade our phones and laptops often. Do you think it is necessary?

Everyone knows that these types of electronic devices lose asset value more than cars.

Even though we know this, why do we keep upgrading them?

A social driving force has been created by commercial organizations that, it is the right thing to do!

An illusion has been created that you will only get social recognition if you constantly upgrade your gadgets.

4.)Buying Depreciating Assets Through Debt 

It is important to remember that when you buy assets through debt, you are paying more for the asset through interest. Apart from taking a home loan for a living, you should avoid buying other assets such as interior decoration, cars, and electronic gadgets through debt.

When you invest in a growing asset, compound interest works in your favor. When you take a loan, compound interest works in favor of your bank and works against you.

Always Remember that compound interest, which is considered the eighth wonder, should be invested in growing assets to work in your favour.

Depreciating Assets and Social Recognition

Depreciating assets are often those that showcase our vanity. Depreciating assets are there to show off our status. People fall into cars, interiors, and phones even though they are depreciating assets because of the attraction of vanity.

One person starts a SIP with his first month’s salary after joining a job. How many likes and shares will he get if he posts it on his social media?

Instead, he buys an iPhone with his first salary. How many likes and shares will he get if he posts it on social media?

This social driving force is what makes us run behind the mirage of depreciating assets.

What is a good home in reality? A home without debt, hatred, and illness is a good home.

Debt occurs when you frequently buy flashy depreciating assets. Flashy depreciating assets stimulate the mind of our neighbors and develop jealousy and hatred.

Moreover, too much time on cell phones, laptops, and smart TVs can affect our health too. 

On top of that, too much time on these very screens can quietly eat into our health and family time.

We are turning our good home into a bad home by putting a curse on it at our own expense. Shouldn’t we wake up now?

5.) Growing Assets – Be Careful!

You may already have a basic understanding of growing assets and depreciating assets. But do you want to take that understanding to the next level? Only with a deep, intrinsic understanding can you make clear decisions about what kind of growing assets to hold to increase your net worth every year.

Some growing assets may appear to be growing on the surface, but they are depreciating on the inside. This is not visible from the outside.

A real growing asset has earned more profit than inflation after income tax. Any investment that has not earned more profit than income tax and inflation is a depreciating asset.

For example, someone invests ₹1 lakh in a bank FD with an interest rate of 6.5%.

He gets  ₹1,06,500 at the end of the year. If his income falls in the 30% tax slab, he will pay income tax (including the 4% cess) of ₹2,028 on the interest amount of ₹6,500.

If his income tax slab is 30%, he will pay an income tax of ₹1,950 on the interest amount of ₹6,500.

After deducting the income tax, he is left with ₹4,472. If inflation runs at 5%, our investment has lost its buying power by ₹528.

But the ₹1 lakh invested, appears to have grown to ₹1,06,500 and then ₹1,04,472 in our mind.

It creates a false impression that our investment has grown.

It is good to avoid such investments that appear to be growing assets on the surface but are depreciating on the inside.

The same test applies to every investment you hold.

Ask yourself one simple question: after tax and after inflation, is this money really growing?

If the answer is no, it may be quietly working like a depreciating asset, even though the balance in your passbook keeps going up.

6.) Conclusion

In this context, Equity Mutual Fund schemes have been a boon for investors who invest for the long term.

Over long periods, they have the potential to beat inflation even after income tax, because long-term equity gains are taxed at a concessional rate and only above an annual exemption limit.

That is what makes them real growing assets. They can increase our net worth!

Mutual fund investments are subject to market risks. Past performance does not guarantee future returns, so please read all scheme-related documents carefully before investing.

Let us invest in growing assets that will truly increase the value of our assets and avoid the illusionary trap of depreciating assets.

At the same time, the right mix of growing assets is different for every family.

It depends on your goals, your time horizon, your tax slab, and how comfortable you are with ups and downs.

This is exactly why we believe in Financial Planning First and Investment Products Second.

If you are not sure whether your money is truly growing after tax and inflation, or how much you can comfortably spend on a car or a home makeover, a conversation can help.

You can book an Initial Guidance Call (No Cost) with our Certified Financial Planner, and we will look at your situation together.

7.) Frequently Asked Questions

Q1. What is the opposite of a depreciating asset?

An appreciating asset is the opposite of a depreciating asset. A depreciating asset, like a car or a phone, loses value over time. An appreciating asset, like equity shares, equity mutual funds, gold or land, has the potential to grow in value over the long term.

Q2. Is a house or flat a depreciating asset in India?

It is a mix of both. The land usually appreciates, while the building and the interiors depreciate as they age. Since a flat owner holds only a small share of the land, a flat’s value depends heavily on its location and the age of the building.

Q3. Is gold an appreciating or a depreciating asset?

Gold is generally treated as an appreciating asset, because its price has tended to rise over long periods. However, it does not pay any interest or dividend, and its price can stay flat or fall for several years. So it works best as one part of a well-planned portfolio.

Q4. Which statement is correct: is investment all about owning appreciating assets or depreciating assets?

Investment is all about owning appreciating assets. The purpose of investing is to put your money into things that can grow in value or earn income over time. Depreciating assets like cars and gadgets are things we buy for use and comfort, not as investments.

Q5. Can buying a depreciating asset ever be a good decision?

Yes, when it meets a real need or helps you earn. A car for your daily commute or a laptop for your work can be sensible purchases. The key is to buy them within a budget, avoid long loans for them, and not mistake them for investments

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top
Secret Link