Listen to this article
Recurring Deposits (RDs) have long been the go-to choice for Indian savers.
But are they truly the best option anymore?
Are your savings actually growing fast enough to beat inflation?
Can you achieve your goals—be it a new home, your child’s education, or a worry-free retirement—by relying solely on RDs?
With rising inflation and evolving financial products, it’s time to rethink your approach.
If you’re looking for safe, rewarding, and goal-based alternatives to RDs, this guide breaks down the top 7 options – ranked by safety, returns, liquidity, and suitability – to help you build a well-diversified investment portfolio that actually works for your goals.
Table of Contents
1. Public Provident Fund (PPF)
2. Sukanya Samriddhi Yojana (SSY)
3. Unit Linked Insurance Plan (ULIP)
4. Endowment / Money Back Policy
6. Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) in Equity Mutual Funds
1. Public Provident Fund (PPF)
Why is PPF #1? It combines government-backed safety with tax-free returns – a rare combo!
- Returns: ~7.1% (tax-free)
- Lock-in: 15 years (partial withdrawal allowed from year 7)
- Risk: Virtually zero (backed by Government of India)
- Taxation: EEE (Exempt-Exempt-Exempt)
✅ Pros:
- Guaranteed, tax-free returns
- Safe for long-term goals like retirement
- Partial liquidity after 7 years
❌ Cons:
- Long lock-in period
- No flexibility in investment amounts after locking in yearly contribution
Example:
If you invest ₹5,000/month in PPF for 15 years, you’ll build a corpus of ~₹16.3 lakhs (at 7.1% interest) – and it’s fully tax-free!
2. Sukanya Samriddhi Yojana (SSY)
Have a daughter under 10?
This is possibly the best long-term investment scheme for her future.
- Returns: ~8.2% (tax-free)
- Eligibility: Girl child under 10 years
- Lock-in: Until age 21 (or marriage after 18)
- Risk: Government-backed
✅ Pros:
- Highest tax-free interest rate among small savings schemes
- EEE tax status
- Ideal for long-term goals like education or marriage
❌ Cons:
- Only for girl children
- Long lock-in period
Example:
Investing ₹3,000/month in SSY for 15 years can yield around ₹15.9 lakhs by maturity at 8.2% returns.
3. Unit Linked Insurance Plan (ULIP)
ULIPs try to mix insurance with investment, but do they succeed?
- What it is: Market-linked insurance plan
- Lock-in: 5 years
- Returns: Depends on market performance
- Tax Benefits: Section 80C + tax-free maturity if conditions are met
✅ Pros:
- Long-term wealth potential
- Tax benefits
- Fund switching options (debt to equity and vice versa)
❌ Cons:
- High charges in early years (up to 5%-7%)
- Low life covers relative to premium
- Limited flexibility
Example:
A ₹3,000/month ULIP for 10 years could yield ₹4–5 lakhs depending on fund performance, but high charges may eat into returns.
ULIPs try to serve both protection and returns but usually underperform compared to Pure Term Insurance or Mutual Funds in isolation.
4. Endowment / Money Back Policy
These are traditional life insurance plans with guaranteed returns.
But are they worth the long wait?
- Returns: ~4%–5% (tax-free)
- Lock-in: Usually 10–20 years
- Risk: Very low
✅ Pros:
- Predictable maturity value
- Capital protection
- Encourages disciplined saving
❌ Cons:
- Returns often don’t beat inflation
- Low insurance cover for the premium paid
- Rigid structure
Example:
Paying ₹4,000/month for 20 years could give you ₹14–15 lakhs, but that’s just ~5% return annually.
Better than idle savings, but underwhelming if your goal is either strong financial protection for your family or real wealth creation.
5. Chit Fund
Chit funds are community savings systems.
Popular in rural and semi-urban India, but are they reliable?
- Returns: Variable (can be 6–10%)
- Risk: High if unregistered; low if regulated
- Liquidity: Depends on bidding cycle
✅ Pros:
- Helps in both saving and borrowing
- Flexible contribution amounts
- Suitable for cash flow management
❌ Cons:
- Risk of fraud in unregistered chit funds
- No standard return; depends on auction timing
Example:
If you pay ₹2,000/month in a 20-member chit fund, you might get ₹40,000 early (at a discount) or wait till the end and get full pay out – returns vary!
Regulated chit funds can support disciplined saving but aren’t reliable for long-term wealth building.
6. Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) in Equity Mutual Funds
Want your money to grow faster than inflation?
SIPs in Equity Mutual Funds are your answer.
- Returns: 10%–15% over the long term
- Risk: Market-linked (moderate to high)
- Liquidity: High (no lock-in for regular mutual funds)
- Taxation: LTCG > ₹1 lakh taxed at 10%
✅ Pros:
- High long-term return potential
- Flexibility in amount and duration
- Professional fund management
❌ Cons:
- Market fluctuations in short term
- Not ideal for less than 5 years
Example:
₹5,000/month for 10 years at 12% return can grow to ~₹11.6 lakhs – much more than what you’d get in any guaranteed return product.
Recommended for Growth: Ideal for long-term wealth creation like retirement or child’s education. But it requires discipline and time.
7. Debt Mutual Funds (Short Duration / Liquid Funds)
Want to park money for 6 months to 3 years?
Debt mutual funds are a smarter RD alternative.
- Returns: ~5%–7%
- Risk: Low to moderate (credit and interest rate risk)
- Liquidity: High
- Taxation: LTCG taxed at 20% with indexation (if held > 3 years)
✅ Pros:
- Better post-tax returns than FDs/RDs (especially for high tax bracket investors)
- Highly liquid
- Suitable for short-term goals
❌ Cons:
- Returns are not fixed
- Slight risk due to market interest rate fluctuations
Example:
Invest ₹5,000/month for 3 years in a liquid/short duration fund, and you could get ~₹2 lakhs – with better tax efficiency than RD.
Recommended for Safety + Flexibility: Great for short-term goals or emergency funds.
Final Thoughts
- Want tax-free, guaranteed returns? Choose PPF or SSY.
- Want to grow wealth in the long run? Consider SIPs in equity mutual funds.
- Need liquidity with safety? Go for Debt mutual funds over RDs.
- Be cautious with ULIPs, endowment plans, and chit funds – they have their purpose, but don’t deliver the best value in most cases.
✅ The key is to match your investment with your goal’s time horizon, risk appetite, and tax profile.
For personalized guidance, consider consulting a Certified Financial Planner (CFP) who can help build a goal-based strategy tailored for you.
FAQs
1. Are these RD alternatives safe?
Yes, options like PPF, SSY, and annuities are extremely safe. Market-linked options like SIPs or debt funds carry some risk but can be mitigated with proper selection.
2. Can I withdraw my money anytime from these alternatives?
Not all. SIPs and debt funds offer high liquidity, but PPF, SSY, and annuities have lock-in periods.
3. Are returns from these options taxable?
PPF and SSY are tax-free. Mutual funds and annuities are subject to tax depending on holding period and income slab.
4. Should I replace my RD entirely?
Not necessarily. But gradually shifting to better-performing alternatives based on your goals can improve your overall portfolio performance.
Leave a Reply