NPS Tier 2 vs Mutual Funds: Which Investment Option Offers Better Returns?

Listen to this article

Is NPS Tier 2 a Better Investment Than Mutual Funds? Can its tax-free rebalancing and low-cost structure make it a more attractive option for investors compared to mutual funds?

Many of us seek tax-free or low-tax investment options, and when comparing Mutual Funds with other products, NPS Tier 2 often comes up. But have we truly considered the key reasons behind our investment choices and the potential drawbacks of alternative products?

This article will explore the pros and cons of using NPS Tier 2 as an alternative to Mutual Funds.

Is NPS Tier 2 a Better Investment Than Mutual Funds?

As many of us know, NPS Tier 2 doesn’t have the lock-in feature that NPS Tier 1 does. The financial world often promotes NPS as one of the most cost-effective pension products, but is the reality as simple as it seems?

NPS Tier 1 is a retirement-focused account with a lock-in period and tax benefits, while NPS Tier 2 offers flexibility with no lock-in but does not provide tax benefits during the investment phase.

Let’s take a closer look at the features of both NPS Tier 1 and NPS Tier 2. What really sets them apart?

Before choosing NPS Tier 2 as an alternative to Mutual Funds, there are a few key points to understand for better decision-making:

1. Can you open an NPS Tier 2 Account without NPS Tier 1? The answer is no. You need to maintain a minimum contribution to your NPS Tier 1 Account each year to keep it active, even if your primary focus is NPS Tier 2.
2. Do you have clarity on the equity portfolio or benchmark followed by NPS Tier 2? Even though benchmarks like BSE 200 or NSE 200 are used, there’s little transparency about the mandate. Some pension funds even invest in mutual funds from their own sister companies. Does this approach give you the control and clarity you need for your investment?
3. What about the debt portfolio? Whether you’re 30 or 58, the same debt portfolio is applied to all investors. Many believe debt equals safety, but does it? Without understanding how the bond market works, moving to a debt portfolio doesn’t automatically protect your money. Can the pension fund manager really control the risks, especially interest rate risk when holding long-term bonds?
4. In simple terms, do you have control or clarity over how your money is being managed? With NPS Tier 2, the lack of a clear mandate means you’re left without insight into the fund manager’s decisions.
5. When it comes to cost, is NPS Tier 2 really as cheap as it seems? As mentioned earlier, it’s not as cost-effective as many believe. Does just the liquidity and low cost make it the right investment choice?
6. While NPS Tier 2 offers tax-efficient rebalancing and low-cost management, it lacks clarity on portfolio control, equity and debt allocations, and has higher taxes at withdrawal, making it less favorable compared to mutual funds.
7. Are you aware of the taxation on NPS Tier 2 gains? Gains from NPS Tier 2 are taxed according to your tax slab. There are no tax benefits during the investment phase (except for central government employees), and withdrawals are subject to heavy taxation.
8. There’s a workaround to avoid tax on NPS Tier 2, moving your accumulated funds to NPS Tier 1 before retirement, which allows you to withdraw up to 60% tax-free. But does this strategy fulfill your need for liquidity? The funds are locked until retirement, and the remaining 40% is taxable. Does this really solve your liquidity concerns?
9. Ultimately, does the tax-free rebalancing make up for the hefty taxes at maturity and the lack of flexibility? Even if you postpone the taxes, you still end up paying a heavy price when you reach maturity or choose to move funds into NPS Tier 1.

Beware

With recent SEBI clarifications, some RIAs, Whom you may think can’t sell or earn commissions, could start recommending insurance products or pushing you to invest in NPS, earning a commission in the process (they are required to disclose this).

Does this create a conflict of interest in the advice they provide? Be cautious of such recommendations moving forward.

Final Takeaway

Considering the lack of clarity on equity and debt portfolios, the misconception about low costs, heavy taxation at withdrawal, and the lack of control over your investments, choosing NPS Tier 2 as an alternative to Mutual Funds may not be the right decision.

Just because NPS Tier 2 offers tax-free rebalancing doesn’t make it a superior product. The most important factor to consider is whether you have full control and transparency over where your money is invested.